All Our Wrong Todays, Elan Mastai


The process of preparing for writing a blog review of a book I have just read falls into one of two methods.  Some books urge me to grab my laptop and throw words onto the screen in a matter of minutes the moment I put it down.  Other books require me to carefully ponder their content and meaning before delicately and rhythmically forming a review over the space of an hour or two.  This book definitely fell into the latter category.

All Our Wrong Todays is a story, set in a technological utopia in 2016, about an unambitious man called Tom who travels in time to a crucial point in his world’s history an accidentally changes the course of events.  After leaving the past, Tom wakes up in a hospital bed in a backwards dystopian style version of 2016, one that looks a lot like the world we live in today.  And to make matters worse, Tom’s alternative family (who are very different to the one he knew from before) are insisting his name is John and that he’s an award-winning architect.  Tom sets off on a mission to reverse the problems he caused before and return to his previous life, only to hit a dilemma about what is right for humanity and himself.

This book is a story about humanity and human relationships disguised as a pseudo-political science fiction novel.  That’s not to say the science fiction element isn’t great because it is.  Every piece of fictional science in the story is explained in a way, by our narrator Tom, that makes it somewhat believable.  Mastai has thought up reasonably logical fixes for every potential plot hole that other stories about time travel suffer from.  As the narrator is not a scientist himself, his explanations of the utopian technology is simple enough to understand and imagine.

I particularly enjoyed the strong theme of familial and romantic relationships.  Tom’s relationships with his family and Penelope, the woman he loves, changes greatly as he enters the new version of 2016.  Although he feels the world is backwards, he begins to realise how the perfect world he came from wasn’t so perfect after all.  It was a technological utopia but he had very few people to love and be close to compared to our 2016.  It’s a story that illustrates how much human emotion can affect our actions and our views of the world.

I think the style of narration – a fictional memoir written by Tom himself – really adds to the story and allows the themes of family and love to shine through.  The narration feels quite meta and occasionally flaky at times but these are the unique side effects of such an alternative way of writing this kind of story.  Throughout the book, Tom insists he is not writing a novel and therefore doesn’t need to follow the typical writing styles and conventions of a novel.  This is especially poignant in the last few chapters, and is something I very much enjoyed following.

Overall I think this book was a fascinating read.  It kept me intrigued and entertained from the first page to the last.  It has been a week since I finished it and I haven’t really been able to stop thinking about it and what it means for our relationships and our views on the world.



2 thoughts on “All Our Wrong Todays, Elan Mastai

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s